Now more than ever, it is important to choose an Accommodator for a reverse exchange carefully. ExStra recommends that potential Exchangors evaluate Accommodators using the following criteria:
Expertise with delayed exchanges does not translate to expertise with reverse exchanges. It is critical to determine whether a potential Accommodator has real expertise and experience with reverses and can therefore ensure that maximum tax deferral is available and that there is no risk of transaction failure. If an Accommodator that you are considering describes reverse exchanges as “very complex” or “risky” or “expensive”, then you may be dealing with an Accommodator that has an antiquated view of reverse exchanges and execution capabilities to match.
A reverse exchange requires more than just a set of documents. Continual investments are required to ensure that the following aspects of each reverse exchange are delivered to each and every Exchangor:
In general, fees for delayed exchanges have risen in the last several years due to the ongoing interest rate climate. QIs earn interest on the cash exchange proceeds they hold and the interest is often a significant component of their revenue. So, the QI’s income from a delayed exchange is not simply the fee but a combination of the fee and the interest earned from the cash that really belongs to the Exchangor. As an Exchangor, if you absolutely must have the cash from the sale of your Old Property available to acquire the New Property, then you are likely forced to use a delayed exchange and face the prospect of the QI holding your cash receiving most of the financial benefit (however small it may be given current interest rates) from your investment capital.
If your circumstances dictate that you must acquire the New Property before selling the Old Property, then a reverse exchange is required. If you are forced into one strategy or the other, then a comparison of fees in somewhat irrelevant and you should simply try to find the best Accommodator with a reasonable fee. “Reasonable” should mean not too high but not too low either. A rock-bottom price is indicative of an Accommodator that is either desperate or one that will do the absolute minimum, resulting in additional risk for the Exchangor in terms of increased likelihood that a reverse will be disqualified by the IRS and/or the relevant state tax authorities and/or increased taxes or cost from other sources. A very high price is indicative of a QI that does not really want reverse exchange business and will only do it – perhaps reluctantly – if they can charge more than the market should bear. Our advice is to compare the processes and the fees (not just one or the other) of potential Accommodators and determine who does the best job for the least fee. Our strong advice is to ensure that no future, unanticipated problems will occur as the result of an Accommodator who does not look into the future on your behalf and make sure it comes out the way you want it to.
If your circumstances suggest that you can choose which strategy to use based on what is optimal, then you should consider the following when including fees in your analysis. In a reverse exchange, there is generally no cash held by a QI for a significant amount of time because the cash has been “put to work” buying the New Property. The Exchangor, in this case, has the benefit of more than one investment asset during the exchange period. In those cases where the assets are incoming-producing, the Exchangor has both the benefits and obligations that come with two sources of rental income during a period of up to 180 days. In many cases, the overlapping rent stream and ongoing depreciation deductions created by a reverse exchange far surpass the increasingly narrow gap between the fees for a delayed exchange and a reverse exchange. Many Exchangors will leave money “on the table” if decisions are made on the basis of “encouragement” from QIs who promote delayed exchanges (because of the business model of the QI) rather than on analysis of the factors that determine ROI during an exchange. Click here for more on tools that we provide to support this type of analysis.